• Home
  • About
    • Contact
  • Services
    • Upholding Marriage
      • Catholic “Prenup”
      • Ask Church to Stop Breakup
      • For Divorce Defendant (local Ohio)
      • For Annulment Defendant
    • Support Groups for Spouses
    • Gift of Self (book)
    • Approved Reconciliation Experts
    • Personalized Assistance
  • Research
    • Catholic “Divorce”
    • Catholic Annulment
    • Ohio Law
    • U.S. Constitution
  • Blog
    • Entreaties
  • Video/Audio
  • Shop
  • Donate
  • Home
  • About
    • Contact
  • Services
    • Upholding Marriage
      • Catholic “Prenup”
      • Ask Church to Stop Breakup
      • For Divorce Defendant (local Ohio)
      • For Annulment Defendant
    • Support Groups for Spouses
    • Gift of Self (book)
    • Approved Reconciliation Experts
    • Personalized Assistance
  • Research
    • Catholic “Divorce”
    • Catholic Annulment
    • Ohio Law
    • U.S. Constitution
  • Blog
    • Entreaties
  • Video/Audio
  • Shop
  • Donate
Müller Shows how New CDF is Wrong

Müller Shows how New CDF is Wrong

  • Posted by Mary's Advocates
  • On October 15, 2023
  • 1 Comments

by Bai Macfarlane

Cardinal Müller on Communion to Adulterers

While the bishops are having their secret synod on synodality in Rome, Cardinal Müller is defending the doctrine of the faith in public.  Müller just issued a public letter explaining why Pope Francis and the new head of the CDF have no authority to reverse the timeless teaching on Communion for divorced and remarried.

A simple way to explain the situation is to consider that 5-3=2.  This is true. When Christ formed the Church, he instructed his bishops to teach the world what He taught.  The Church has God’s promise that when it authoritatively defines a matter on doctrines of faith or morals, the Church will be correct.  Bishops don’t have any power to invent random notions on faith and morals because God established these truths.

If Scripture and the Church’s magisterium taught that 5-3=2, the Catholic faithful would be bound to believe it. Moreover, adhering to this truth would result in human flourishing.  If a Cardinal in charge of the CDF (now called Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith) wrote a letter saying that 5-3=1, and got the Pope to sign it, the faithful should not believe them.  This is what is happening now with the newfangled notion that unrepentant adulterers can be admitted to Holy Communion.

Müller used to be in charge of the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith and he was fired by Pope Francis and replaced by Cardinal Victor Fernández.  On September 25, Cardinal Fernández issued a letter to Czech bishops (co-signed by Pope Francis) that purports to issue new magisterially-binding teaching that opens the door to giving Communion to unrepentant adulterers in second marriages.  On October 13, however, Cardinal Muller issued a letter to Czech Cardinal, Dominik Duka. Müller explains why the faithful are bound to disobey Fernández and the Pope who claim that Fernàndez’ innovations “must be given a religious submission of mind and will.”

You can read journalist Sandro Magister’s chronology of events and Cardinal Müller’s letter,“Exclusive. Müller Writes to Duka: Fernández Goes Against Catholic Doctrine, and With Him Is the Pope.”

Müller’s letter to the Czech Cardinal includes the following gems:

“Magisterium cannot teach what has nothing to do with Revelation, nor what is explicitly contrary to Sacred Scripture (“norma normans non normata”), the Apostolic Tradition, and the previous definitive decisions of the Magisterium itself (“Dei Verbum” 10; cf. DH 3116-3117).

“For it happens that the teaching of the ‘Risposta’ [i.e. Fernández’ letter] is contrary to other teachings of the Church, which are not only affirmations of the ordinary Magisterium, but have been taught in a definitive way as belonging to the deposit of faith.

“In fact, the teachings of John Paul II, Benedict XVI and of the Council of Trent bear witness to the Word of God, to which the Magisterium ministers. All pastoral care for Catholics in second marriages after a civil divorce must be based on this witness, because only obedience to the will of God can serve the salvation of persons.

“the mercy of the Gospel does not consist in tolerating sin, but in regenerating the heart of the faithful, so that they may live according to the fullness of the love that Christ lived himself and taught us to live.

“But let us put this last point aside to focus on the surprising affirmation made by the DDF [i.e. Fernández’ letter]. It turns out that the faithful themselves decide whether or not to receive absolution, and the priest only has to accept this decision! If we apply this conclusion to all sins, the Sacrament of Reconciliation loses its Catholic meaning. Confession is no longer the humble request for forgiveness of one who stands before a merciful judge, the priest, who receives his authority from Christ Himself, but it is a self-absolution after having examined one’s own life.

“It is astonishing that the DDF could present to the Holy Father for his signature, in the course of an audience, a text with such theological flaws, thus compromising the authority of the Holy Father.

“As can be seen, the DDF has selected a small part of the text of St. John Paul II, while omitting the main argument, which is contrary to the argument made by the DDF.

The second innovation included in the “Risposta” is that each diocese is encouraged to develop its own guidelines for this discernment.” … “Therefore, for a person to be able to receive communion in one local Church and not in another is an exact definition of schism.” 

 

1 Comment

R. Doerflinger
  • Oct 17 2023
  • Reply
To be exact, Cardinal Mueller served as prefect for a five-year term, 2012-2017, which was not renewed. He was replaced by Archbishop Luis Ladaria Ferrer for a five-year term, 2017-2022, who was then replaced by Cardinal Fernandez this year.

Leave Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search
Sign up for Newsletter

Book Challenges Annulment Culture

Previous thumb

Moral Injury Divorced Persons

Next thumb
Scroll
©Mary's Advocates. 501(c)(3) nonprofit
Please Help Spread the Word

To uphold Marriage, we need your help. $5150 is total monthly goal regularly.

Thank You,
Bai Macfarlane, Mary’s Advocates. We are a 501(c)(3) non-profit.